Super Mario 64 Nintendo 64 Game Cartridge

Nintendo · Toys & Games > Video Games

Super Mario 64 Nintendo 64 Game Cartridge

Era / Decade

Mid-1990s (Released 1996); dating clues include the "K-A" (Kids to Adults) ESRB rating which was replaced by "E" (Everyone) in 1998.

Material

Gray acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) plastic casing, electronic PCB (Printed Circuit Board) with ROM chip, and laminated paper label.

Condition

Very Good; the front label is intact with vibrant colors and no peeling, though there is minor edge wear. The plastic shell appears clean without yellowing or major cracks.

Demand Level

Hot; this is a 'blue-chip' retro gaming title that sells consistently well year-round.

Resale Value

Estimated Resale Value

$40.00 - $55.00 for the loose cartridge in current market conditions.

Estimated Retail Value

$59.99 (Original 1996 MSRP)

Comparable Sales

Recent eBay sold listings show loose authentic cartridges selling between $42.00 and $58.00 depending on label condition and if they have been professionally cleaned/tested.

Description

An authentic Super Mario 64 video game for the Nintendo 64 console. This is the North American (NTSC-U) version, model NUS-006 (USA). Features the iconic front label with Mario and Bowser and the Kids to Adults ESRB rating.

Key Features

High brand recognition; essential title for N64 collectors; authentic 'Players Choice' alternative with original label; high liquidity in the retro gaming market.

Authenticity Indicators

High confidence. Visible features include a correctly numbered '00' or '22' punch stamp on the back label (not visible in image but typical), specific texture of the plastic, and the correct font/kerning on the Nintendo logo. Red flags would be a 'dotted' i in the Nintendo logo on the back or a missing internal heat shield.

Flaws to Note

Minor surface scratches on the plastic shell; light edge wear on the top of the label. Functional status is unknown without testing on a console.

Selling Guide

Where to Sell

eBay (for highest reach), Mercari (low fees), or Facebook Marketplace (local cash sale, no fees).

Selling Tips

Clean the brass connector pins with a Q-tip and 90%+ isopropyl alcohol before selling. Take a clear photo of the top edge showing the label condition and a photo of the back of the cartridge. Use keywords like 'Authentic', 'N64', 'Super Mario 64', and 'Tested'.

Appraised on 7/10/2026
Super Mario 64 Nintendo 64 Game Cartridge - Nintendo | Thrift Scanner