Old Master Sterling Silver Hollow Handle Cake/Pie Server with Stainless Blade
Towle Silversmiths · Kitchenware > Sterling Flatware
Era / Decade
Mid-20th Century (Pattern introduced in 1942)
Material
Sterling Silver handle with a high-polish Stainless Steel blade. The handle is hollow-ware construction, typical for serving pieces.
Condition
Very Good. The handle shows minor surface scratches consistent with use. The blade appears straight with no heavy pitting. Light tarnish is present which is easily removable.
Demand Level
Strong. 'Old Master' is a foundational pattern for collectors, meaning there is always a buyer looking to complete or expand a set.
Resale Value
Estimated Resale Value
$45.00 - $65.00 Low; $75.00 - $95.00 Mid; $110.00 - $130.00 High (pattern-specific premium)
Estimated Retail Value
$150.00 - $225.00 (Current replacement price for new/estate sterling server)
Comparable Sales
Recent eBay 'Sold' listings for Towle Old Master pie servers range from $68.00 (worn condition) to $115.00 (polished/excellent condition). Sets with original boxes can fetch up to $140.00.
Description
Exquisite Towle 'Old Master' sterling silver cake and pie server. This elegant piece features a detailed scrolling floral and shell motif handle, hallmark to one of the most popular sterling patterns in history. The server has a wide, mirror-polished stainless steel blade designed for effortless serving of desserts. A timeless heirloom piece for holiday tables or weddings.
Key Features
Highly collectible 'Old Master' pattern; solid sterling silver handle; high demand for wedding and holiday gift market; easy to ship; retains intrinsic silver value.
Authenticity Indicators
High confidence. Clearly stamped 'TOWLE' and 'STERLING' on the bolster/neck of the handle. The pattern design is consistent with authentic 1942 Towle molds.
Flaws to Note
Minor surface 'scuffs' on the stainless blade; light tarnish in the recessed areas of the silver handle (easily cleaned with silver cloth). No deep gouges or 'garbage disposal' damage.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
eBay (best for pattern collectors and worldwide reach) or Etsy (strong for vintage wedding supplies). Replacement sites like Replacements, Ltd. will buy it but at a lower wholesale rate.
Selling Tips
Polish the silver handle to a high shine before photographing to make it pop. Use keywords like 'Towle Old Master', 'Sterling Silver Handle', 'Cake Server', and 'Wedding Gift'. Ship in a sturdy box, not a padded envelope, to prevent the blade from bending.