Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer Plush with Collar
Precious Moments / CVS (Likely for Character Arts, LLC) · Toys & Games > Stuffed Animals & Plush
Era / Decade
Late 1990s to Early 2000s (approx. 1998-2002)
Material
Polyester fibers, synthetic velboa/plush fabric, embroidered eyes, felt/fabric nose.
Condition
Good to Very Good. The plush shows some minor flattening of the 'fur' on the head. The white collar is present but appears slightly yellowed or frayed at the edge. No major stains or tears visible.
Demand Level
Moderate (Peaking in November and December). This is a 'filler' item rather than a high-end collectible, but it sells consistently during the holidays.
Resale Value
Estimated Resale Value
$10.00 - $18.00 (Low-Mid-High range depending on seasonal demand and tag presence)
Estimated Retail Value
$5.00 - $9.99 (Original promotional price at pharmacies or department stores)
Comparable Sales
Similar unboxed Rudolph plushies from this era typically sell for $8-$12 plus shipping. If it had the original heart-shaped Precious Moments tag, it could reach $20-$25.
Description
Vintage Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer plush standing approximately 6-8 inches tall. Features a soft tan body, iconic red nose, black 'hooves,' and a tuft of blonde hair. Includes the original white fabric collar with 'Rudolph' printed in red script. Stylized 'Precious Moments' style eyes suggest this is part of a specific licensed collection from the late 90s.
Key Features
Nostalgic holiday appeal, presence of the original 'Rudolph' collar which is often lost, compact size ideal for stocking stuffers or Tiered Tray decor, recognizable Rankin/Bass character design.
Authenticity Indicators
High confidence. The specific eye style and collar font are consistent with the mass-produced CVS/Precious Moments holiday releases of the late 90s. Check the 'tush tag' for a Character Arts, LLC copyright.
Flaws to Note
Fraying/wear on the collar ribbon; slight discoloration of the white fabrics due to age; hair tuft may require gentle brushing; missing original paper hang tags (tush tag only).
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
eBay (best for vintage plush collectors) or Mercari (good for quick sales and low shipping costs). Facebook Marketplace is a good option in December for local pickup to avoid shipping fees.
Selling Tips
List this as 'Vintage Rudolph Plush' and use keywords like 'Rankin Bass,' 'Red Nose Reindeer,' 'Holiday Decor,' and 'Misfit Toys.' Take photos against a dark background so the light tan fur pops. Best sold as part of a lot if you have other characters (Hermey, Bumble, Clarice) to increase profit margins.