Walt Disney Presents The Story of Treasure Island Vinyl LP - DQ-1251

Disneyland Records · Books & Media > Vinyl Records

Walt Disney Presents The Story of Treasure Island Vinyl LP - DQ-1251

Era / Decade

1964 (indicated by the copyright date on the cover lower right)

Material

Vinyl record with a cardboard gatefold or sleeve jacket; paper labels.

Condition

Fair to Good. Visible corner wear, edge fraying (shelf wear), and surface scratches on the cover. There appears to be handwriting (name) at the top and bottom right. Scoring: Sleeve C- / Vinyl Unknown (assuming G based on sleeve).

Demand Level

Moderate (Niche for Disneyana collectors and vintage vinyl enthusiasts).

Resale Value

Estimated Resale Value

$8.00 - $18.00

Estimated Retail Value

$1.98 - $2.98 (Original 1960s retail price)

Comparable Sales

Recent eBay sales for the DQ-1251 pressing range from $5 (poor condition) to $25 (near mint). Given the handwriting on the cover, this piece sits at the lower end of that spectrum.

Description

Vintage 1964 Disneyland Records release of 'The Story of Treasure Island'. This LP features the complete story from the original soundtrack of the Walt Disney motion picture, based on the classic Robert Louis Stevenson novel. Cover art by Paul Wensel. Includes narration and musical score. Catalog number DQ-1251.

Key Features

Nostalgic Disney collectible; features iconic Paul Wenzel cover art; original soundtrack audio; rare yellow board version.

Authenticity Indicators

Standard Disneyland Records logo and catalog number (DQ-1251) present. 1964 copyright notice. High confidence in authenticity.

Flaws to Note

Significant shelf wear on edges; split seams likely; heavy handwriting/signature on the front cover in ink (Nancy Burnett); surface scuffing. Value depends heavily on the condition of the actual vinyl inside.

Selling Guide

Where to Sell

eBay (best for reaching Disney collectors), Discogs (best for vinyl enthusiasts), or Etsy (for vintage decor appeal).

Selling Tips

Always show photos of the actual vinyl disk to prove it isn't cracked or warped. Mention 'Paul Wenzel cover art' in the title. Ship in a dedicated cardboard record mailer to prevent further damage. Clean the sleeve gently with a dry microfiber cloth before photographing.

Appraised on 7/15/2026