Wendy the Frog Squishmallows (5-inch Plush)
Kellytoy (a subsidiary of Jazwares) · Toys & Games > Stuffed Animals
Era / Decade
Early 2020s; Wendy is part of the original squad, but this 5-inch iteration is a modern production (circa 2021-2023).
Material
Super soft spandex 'marshmallow' polyester fabric with polyester fiber filling.
Condition
Very Good to Excellent. The item still has its plastic swift tach attached, though the cardboard hang tag appears partially missing or bent. The plush surface looks clean with no visible stains or pilling.
Demand Level
Strong. Squishmallows maintain a dedicated fan base, and frogs are among the most collected animal types. 5-inch versions sell quickly due to lower shipping costs.
Resale Value
Estimated Resale Value
$8.00 (Low) - $12.00 (Mid) - $18.00 (High if tag is intact).
Estimated Retail Value
$4.99 - $6.99 (standard MSRP for 5-inch 'mini' Squishmallows at Five Below or Walgreens).
Comparable Sales
Recent sold listings on Mercari for a tagless 5" Wendy range from $7-$10, while those with mint tags consistently reach $15-$22 plus shipping.
Description
Authentic Wendy the Frog Squishmallow in the 5-inch mini size. Features a vibrant lime green body, white belly, embroidered pink cheeks, and a sweet smile. Known for the signature ultra-soft, marshmallow-like texture. This is a highly sought-after character within the Squishmallows collector community.
Key Features
High brand recognition; Wendy is a fan-favorite 'OG' character; portable 5-inch scale is popular for 'squad' collecting; gender-neutral appeal; machine washable.
Authenticity Indicators
High confidence. Correct embroidery patterns on the eyes and cheeks; proper 'butt tag' (loop label) visible at the bottom; correct fabric sheen and stitch tension characteristic of Kellytoy production.
Flaws to Note
The paper hang tag appears to be damaged or missing the main face (only the plastic attachment and possibly the back of the tag are visible). Collectors prefer mint condition tags.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
Mercari is the top choice for Squishmallows due to the high concentration of collectors. eBay and Depop are also excellent for plushies. Facebook Marketplace/Squishmallow BST groups avoid fees.
Selling Tips
Highlight 'WENDY' and 'FROG' in the title. Mention the 5-inch size explicitly. Use a white background for photos to make the green pop. If the paper tag is missing, be transparent as it affects value for 'NWT' (New With Tag) collectors. Ship in a poly mailer to keep costs low (under 4oz).