NYX Butter Gloss (Potential Shade: Peaches and Cream or Strawberry Cheesecake)
NYX Professional Makeup · Health & Beauty > Makeup > Lip Gloss
Era / Decade
2020s (Modern production)
Material
Plastic tube and applicator; Lip gloss formula containing mineral oil, polybutene, and silica dimethyl silylate.
Condition
Poor to Fair. The product appears used, with significant wear and a missing or damaged bottom label where the shade name and batch code are normally located.
Demand Level
Low (due to condition). While the brand is high-demand, used lip products have extremely low resale value for hygiene reasons.
Resale Value
Estimated Resale Value
$0.00 - $2.00
Estimated Retail Value
$5.00 - $6.00
Comparable Sales
New, sealed NYX Butter Glosses typically sell in bundles of 3-5 for $10-$15. Single used units have no recorded successful sales on major platforms.
Description
A used NYX Butter Gloss in a pink/coral shade. This cult-favorite lip product is known for its non-sticky shine and sheer-to-medium coverage. The tube is plastic with an orange-toned cap.
Key Features
Popular brand and affordable 'holy grail' status in the beauty community; lightweight and moisturizing formula.
Authenticity Indicators
Tube shape and cap style match standard NYX Butter Gloss packaging. High confidence it is a genuine mass-market product, but low value due to condition.
Flaws to Note
Significant cosmetic damage to the bottom of the tube; shade label is missing; secondary safety seal is broken; item is clearly used, posing hygiene risks for resale.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
Not recommended for resale. Standard marketplaces like Poshmark and Mercari have strict policies against selling used lip glosses/applicators.
Selling Tips
Do not attempt to resell used makeup of this type. It is a health hazard. This item is best for personal use or discarded. If it were New With Tags (NWT), it would be best as a 'bundle filler' on Poshmark.