Vintage Nantucket Pique Cotton Polo Shirt
The Nobby Clothes Shop · Clothing & Accessories > Men's Tops > Polo Shirts
Era / Decade
1980s or 1990s based on the woven black tag design and the history of this established Nantucket boutique which closed its main brick-and-mortar operations in the mid-2010s.
Material
100% Cotton Pique. High-quality textured knit, typical of breathable preppy coastal wear. Features natural horn-effect or resin buttons.
Condition
Good to Very Good. The fabric shows minor pilling and some yellowing/discoloration near the neckline and inner collar consistent with age and storage. No visible holes or structural damage.
Demand Level
Moderate to High (Specialized). Extremely high demand among vintage 'Preppy' collectors and fans of New England coastal brands like Murray’s Toggery.
Resale Value
Estimated Resale Value
$25.00 - $45.00
Estimated Retail Value
$65.00 - $85.00 (original boutique pricing relative to high-end resort wear)
Comparable Sales
Similar vintage Nantucket-specific boutique polos (Nobby Shop or Murray’s) typically sell for $30-$50 on eBay and Poshmark depending on color and condition.
Description
Authentic vintage white pique cotton polo shirt from the legendary 'The Nobby Clothes Shop' of Nantucket. This classic piece features a short-sleeve construction, ribbed collar, and two-button placket. Perfect for those seeking the 'Old Money' or 'Coastal Grandmillennial' aesthetic. Made for the exclusive Nantucket resort market.
Key Features
Niche boutique branding (The Nobby Shop is a known Nantucket icon), sought-after coastal/preppy aesthetic, high-quality pique knit, vintage status.
Authenticity Indicators
Genuine vintage woven black and white label featuring the Nobby Shop house logo and 'Nantucket' location text. High confidence in authenticity (95%+).
Flaws to Note
Faint yellowing/sweat staining around the interior collar band. Mild pilling on the chest area. Minor fraying on the edge of the woven brand tag.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
eBay, Poshmark, and Depop are best. Depop is ideal for the younger 'vintage preppy' demographic, while eBay captures the older Nantucket memorabilia collectors.
Selling Tips
Use keywords like 'Nantucket', 'Old Money', 'Preppy', 'Coastal', and 'Ivy League'. Treat the collar with an OxiClean soak to remove the yellowing before photographing. Take clear shots of the specialized brand tag.