Vintage 1996 Eastman 'A' Flight Club Champion Trophy Pitcher/Teapot
Unbranded (likely a trophy manufacturer like Woodbury Pewter or Wilton) · Collectibles & Antiques > Metalware > Pewter
Era / Decade
1990s (Dated 1996 based on engraving)
Material
Pewter or Pewter-finish Aluminum. It has a matte, non-reflective finish typical of lead-free pewter.
Condition
Fair to Good. There is significant surface scratching, scuffing, and some dark oxidation spots near the lettering. The engraving is faded in areas.
Demand Level
Low. Personalized trophies are difficult to sell unless the brand or recipient is famous (e.g., Eastman Kodak or a pro golfer).
Resale Value
Estimated Resale Value
$15 - $25
Estimated Retail Value
$65 - $85 (Comparable price for a high-quality solid pewter tavern pitcher)
Comparable Sales
Generic vintage pewter pitchers typically sell for $10-$20 at estate sales; personalized champion trophies from the 90s regularly sell for $15-$25 on eBay to collectors of sport memorabilia.
Description
A classic bulbous trophy pitcher featuring a satin pewter finish and a hinged lid. The front is engraved with 'Eastman', 'A Flight Club Champion', '1996', and the recipient name 'Bill Montross'. Likely awarded for a golf or local country club achievement.
Key Features
Functional pouring vessel with a hinged lid; heavy-weight construction; genuine 1990s provenance; desirable for cottagecore or 'dark academia' decor styles.
Authenticity Indicators
Modern pewter finish; engraving style consistent with 1990s trophy shops; lack of hallmark indicates it is likely a mass-produced trophy blank. Confidence: High.
Flaws to Note
Heavy surface scratches and abrasions around the midsection; black oxidation spots (pitting) that may be permanent; personalized engraving which limits the buyer pool.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
Facebook Marketplace, Etsy (for decor), or eBay. Local sales are best to avoid shipping costs that exceed the item's value.
Selling Tips
Market this as 'Vintage Decor' or 'Barware' rather than just a trophy. Use keywords like 'Pewter Pitcher', 'Satin Finish', and 'Golf Trophy'. Do not attempt to polish with harsh abrasives, as it will ruin the satin finish.