Vintage Cobalt Blue Glazed Stoneware Butter Dish in Cherry and Paneled Pattern
Unbranded (likely McCoy, Robinson Ransbottom, or similar mid-century pottery maker) · Kitchenware > Serving Dishes
Era / Decade
1940s-1950s (Mid-Century); identified by the heavy stoneware construction and the characteristic blue/white spongeware or 'cold painted' glazing style common in that era.
Material
Heavy stoneware ceramic with a high-shine cobalt blue glaze. Quality is high due to the weight and thick walls of the piece.
Condition
Very Good; appears to be a complete two-piece set (base and lid). No visible deep cracks or heavy chips in the photo, though the wrap obscures fine details. There is minor glaze pop/crazing consistent with age.
Demand Level
Moderate to Strong. Blue and white kitchenware is an evergreen category with a steady buyer base on platforms like Etsy and eBay.
Resale Value
Estimated Resale Value
$25.00 - $45.00 (Low: $20, Mid: $35, High: $50+ depending on maker's mark under the wrap).
Estimated Retail Value
$10.00 - $15.00 (original historical price adjusted for inflation) or $45.00 for a modern artisan equivalent.
Comparable Sales
Similar unbranded 1950s blue butter dishes typically sell for $28-$35 on eBay. If identified specifically as McCoy or Hull, the price can reach $55-$75 depending on the rarity of the color.
Description
This charming vintage butter dish features a deep cobalt blue and white ombré/spongeware glaze. The domed lid is decorated with a raised cherry fruit motif and architectural paneling, topped with a faceted finial. The matching scalloped base provides a wide ledge for the lid to sit securely. Perfect for farmhouse, country, or MCM kitchen decor.
Key Features
Highly desirable cobalt blue color; classic fruit motif; complete set with lid; heavy, durable stoneware; excellent crossover appeal for both vintage kitchen collectors and modern farmhouse decorators.
Authenticity Indicators
Weight and bottom wear are the main indicators. Authentic vintage stoneware will have an unglazed 'foot' or bottom rim and a heavy feel. Confidence: High (it is a genuine vintage item, though exact manufacturer is TBD).
Flaws to Note
Possibility of 'flea bites' (tiny chips) along the inner rim where the lid meets the base. Potential crazing (fine spiderweb lines in glaze). Check for a black marker line on the base plate—this might be a thrift store price mark that requires cleaning.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
Etsy (best for vintage decor), eBay (best for collectors look for specific marks), or Facebook Marketplace (good for local sales to avoid shipping fragile stoneware).
Selling Tips
Remove the plastic wrap and thrift price markings before photographing. Use the keywords 'Cobalt Blue', 'Stoneware', 'Cherry Motif', and 'Farmhouse Decor'. Highlight that it is a 2-piece set. Double-box this item for shipping to prevent breakage.