Too Faced x Erika Jayne 'Pretty Mess' Eyeshadow Palette
Too Faced · Clothing & Accessories > Makeup & Cosmetics
Era / Decade
2019 (Limited Edition Collaboration)
Material
Pressed powder pigments in a high-quality cardboard palette with magnetic closure, holographic embossed overlay, and internal mirror.
Condition
Good. The exterior shows visible scratching, surface wear on the holographic finish, and structural indentation on the left side. The internal state (usage of powders) is not visible in the photo but is critical for value.
Demand Level
Niche. Highly sought after by 'Real Housewives' fans and makeup collectors, but general interest has waned since its 2019 release.
Resale Value
Estimated Resale Value
$25.00 - $45.00 (Highly dependent on internal usage)
Estimated Retail Value
$42.00
Comparable Sales
Recent sales on eBay and Poshmark show New-In-Box (NIB) units selling for $60-$80, while used/swatched units typically sell for $20-$35 depending on usage levels.
Description
Authentic Too Faced x Erika Jayne 'Pretty Mess' 12-pan eyeshadow palette. This limited edition collaboration features a pink grid pattern with gold embossed lettering and Erika Jayne's signature. Palette includes a mix of matte, shimmer, and glitter shades with names like 'Expensive,' 'So Chic,' and '富/Wealthy.'
Key Features
Discontinued limited edition; high-profile celebrity collaboration with Real Housewife Erika Jayne; holographic packaging; nostalgic Y2K/noughties aesthetic; rare collectible status for Too Faced enthusiasts.
Authenticity Indicators
High confidence. Correct typography for the 'Too Faced' logo; characteristic 'Erika Jayne' signature placement; high-quality embossing depth; correct color shift on the holographic border.
Flaws to Note
Significant surface scratching on the 'PRETTY ME$$' lettering and holographic trim; visible vertical creasing/denting on the left edge of the cover art; potential hygiene concerns if the product has been swatched or used.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
Poshmark or Mercari are ideal for used/pre-owned cosmetics. eBay is suitable for reaching international collectors of discontinued makeup.
Selling Tips
Open the palette and take clear, high-resolution photos of the eyeshadow pans under natural light. State clearly if the item is 'Swatched Only' or used. Sanitize the exterior with 70% isopropyl alcohol. Use keywords: Erika Girardi, RHOBH, XXpen$ive, Discontinued, Rare.