Johnston & Murphy Melton Cap Toe Oxford
Johnston & Murphy · Clothing & Accessories > Men's Shoes > Dress Shoes
Era / Decade
Modern (2010s-2020s) based on standard silhouette and interior stamped serial numbers
Material
Full-grain calfskin leather upper, sheepskin lining, and a Goodyear welt construction with a leather/rubber composite sole
Condition
Good to Very Good. The uppers show moderate creasing and some light scuffing on the toe. The interior lining is intact but shows darkening from wear. The welting is solid.
Demand Level
Moderate to Strong. This is a staple 'entry-level' luxury dress shoe that sells consistently for office-goers and wedding attendees.
Resale Value
Estimated Resale Value
$35.00 - $65.00
Estimated Retail Value
$175.00 - $195.00
Comparable Sales
Recent eBay sold listings for pre-owned J&M Melton oxfords in similar condition range from $38.00 to $55.00 plus shipping. NIB (New in Box) pairs fetch $110+.
Description
Classic Men's Johnston & Murphy Melton Cap Toe Oxfords in a rich dark brown (mahogany/burgundy) leather. These feature a traditional 5-eyelet lace-up design, Goodyear welt construction allowing for easy resoling, and padded sheepskin linings for comfort. Size 10.5. Perfect for business formal or semi-formal attire.
Key Features
Goodyear Welt construction is a high-value indicator for shoe enthusiasts; Timeless 'Melton' model; Full-grain leather uppers; Versatile mahogany colorway.
Authenticity Indicators
High confidence. Johnston & Murphy standard internal gold/white stamped serial codes (visible as '20 01644' in the photo) and characteristic welt stitching consistent with authentic production.
Flaws to Note
Visible creasing across the vamp (toe box); light surface scuffs on the leather that require buffing; minor wear on the heel drag; laces are slightly frayed and may need replacement.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
eBay (best for searchability), Poshmark (strong for men's fashion), or Mercari. Local Facebook Marketplace for a quick cash flip if priced low.
Selling Tips
Condition the leather with a high-quality cream like Bick 4 or Saphir to reduce the appearance of creases. Use cedar shoe trees for photos to maintain shape. Include keywords like 'Business Professional', 'Goodyear Welted', 'Classic', and 'Interview' in the title.
Notes
Johnston and Murphy 10.5