Miss America Pink/Clear Glass Covered Butter Dish (Lid Only)
Hocking Glass Company · Kitchenware > Serving Trays & Dishes
Era / Decade
Depression Era (1935-1938)
Material
Pressed 'Crystal' Clear Glass. High-quality heavy lead-free glass typical of the Depression era with a high refractive index that gives it a sparkling diamond effect.
Condition
Excellent. No visible chips to the diamond points (frequent in this pattern) or the faceted finial. Note: This appears to be only the lid/top portion of a two-piece butter dish.
Demand Level
Moderate - Replacement pieces have a steady niche market for collectors looking to complete sets.
Resale Value
Estimated Resale Value
Low: $12.00 | Mid: $22.00 | High: $30.00 (Lid only value for replacement market)
Estimated Retail Value
$45.00 - $65.00 (for full original set in 1930s equivalent value)
Comparable Sales
Full butter dishes (base and lid) sell for $45-$60. Isolated lids generally sell for $18-$25 plus shipping to collectors who have broken their original tops.
Description
Beautiful vintage Hocking Glass Miss America pattern butter dish lid. Features the iconic 'Diamond and Sunburst' pressed glass design. The lid has a tall, faceted knob finial and a domed shape. Measuring approximately 4-5 inches in diameter, this crystal clear glass catches light brilliantly. Perfect as a replacement piece or used as a decorative cloche/candle topper.
Key Features
Highly collectible 'Miss America' Depression glass pattern; discontinued for over 80 years; iconic diamond point texture; crystal clarity; high secondary market for replacement lids.
Authenticity Indicators
The 'Diamond' points are sharp to the touch, which is a hallmark of original Miss America glass. Look for a slight straw mark or mold line on the finial. Confidence Level: High.
Flaws to Note
The primary 'flaw' is that the bottom tray is missing. To maximize value, you would need the matching circular base tray. Check for micro-flea bites along the bottom rim and the sharp diamond edges.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
eBay is the best platform due to the specific 'replacement' nature of the item. Etsy is a secondary option for vintage decor lovers. Facebook Marketplace is less ideal as local demand for single lids is low.
Selling Tips
In your title, use keywords: 'Miss America Glass', 'Hocking Glass', 'Depression Glass', 'Replacement Lid', and 'Diamond Pattern'. Take photos against a dark background to highlight the glass patterns. Offer careful double-boxing and bubble wrap during shipping as this glass is brittle.