Pinwheel and Star Pattern Pressed Glass Butter Dish Dome (Lid Only)
Unbranded (Attributed to Indiana Glass or similar EAPG manufacturers) · Kitchenware > Serving Trays & Accessories
Era / Decade
1960s-1970s (Mid-Century Revival)
Material
Pressed clear glass; thick-walled with machine-pressed intricate patterns. High lead content likely based on clarity.
Condition
Very Good. Visible clarity is high with no major clouding. No visible chips to the finial or bottom rim in the image, though these are common wear areas.
Demand Level
Niche/Low. While the pattern is popular, selling 'lids only' requires waiting for a buyer who specifically needs a replacement.
Resale Value
Estimated Resale Value
$8.00 - $18.00 (as a replacement lid/orphan piece)
Estimated Retail Value
$15.00 - $25.00 (as part of a complete set with original underplate)
Comparable Sales
Similar vintage pressed glass butter dish lids typically sell for $10-$15 plus shipping on eBay. Complete sets (with base) range from $20-$35.
Description
Vintage clear pressed glass dome lid featuring a classic 'Pinwheel and Star' or 'Buzz Saw' pattern. This heavy glass piece was originally part of a circular butter dish or small cheese server. It features a ribbed button finial and deeply textured geometric cuts that catch the light beautifully. Dimensions appear to be approximately 5-6 inches in diameter.
Key Features
Timeless geometric pattern, popular with collectors of Early American Presale Glass (EAPG) styles; heavy, high-quality feel; serves as a vital replacement part for someone with a broken set.
Authenticity Indicators
Seam lines from the press mold are present but faint; lack of maker's marks is standard for mass-produced glass of this era. Confidence Level: High (Mass-market vintage).
Flaws to Note
Flea bites (tiny chips) along the bottom inner rim are common and should be checked for by touch. Slight 'sick glass' (cloudiness) can occur from dishwasher use, but this piece appears clear.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
eBay or Etsy. These platforms are best for 'Replacement Part' buyers. Use local marketplaces only if bundled with other glassware.
Selling Tips
Use keywords like 'Replacement Lid', 'Butter Dish Dome', 'Pinwheel Pattern', and 'Star Cut Glass'. Take a photo from the top down and a clear shot of the bottom rim. Measure the outer and inner diameter exactly to ensure buyer compatibility.