Christmas Heritage 'Cookies for Santa' 9-Inch Serving Plate
Pfaltzgraff · Kitchenware > Holiday Tableware
Era / Decade
1980s-1990s; the pattern was introduced in the early 1980s and the box typography is consistent with that era.
Material
Stoneware; high-quality durable glazed ceramic noted for being microwave, oven, and dishwasher safe.
Condition
Very Good. The plate itself appears glossy with no visible chips or cracks. The original box reflects 'Good' condition with shelf wear and a partial price sticker, which adds value for collectors but shows its age.
Demand Level
Strong (Seasonal); demand peaks significantly from October through December. It maintains a niche following year-round for pattern replacements.
Resale Value
Estimated Resale Value
$12.00 (low) - $18.00 (mid) - $25.00 (high with box and seasonal demand)
Estimated Retail Value
$15.00 - $20.00 (comparable new holiday stoneware plates)
Comparable Sales
Sold listings for this specific 'Cookies for Santa' variant typically range from $14 to $22 on eBay. Pieces including the box frequently command the higher end of the range.
Description
A charming Pfaltzgraff 'Cookies for Santa' plate from the popular Christmas Heritage collection. Features the iconic decorated Christmas tree with a village scene base and green trim on a white stoneware body. Comes in the original red presentation box.
Key Features
Includes original box; part of a highly collected discontinued pattern; 'Cookies for Santa' text makes it a specific functional holiday tradition piece; high brand recognition.
Authenticity Indicators
Clear 'Christmas Heritage by Pfaltzgraff' branding on the box; Pfaltzgraff castle/potter mark should be present on the bottom of the plate. Confidence: High.
Flaws to Note
Shelf wear, scuffing, and old price sticker residue on the cardboard box. Minimal utensil marks or 'crazing' (fine surface cracks in glaze) may be present upon close inspection but are not visible in photo.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
eBay is best for reach; Etsy is great for vintage holiday decor; Facebook Marketplace is good for local sales to avoid shipping fragile stoneware.
Selling Tips
List this immediately in early Q4 (October/November). Use keywords like 'Vintage Pfaltzgraff', 'NIB' (New in Box), and 'Holiday Tradition'. Wrap the plate in heavy bubble wrap inside the box, then double-box for shipping to ensure it survives transit.